Outside withdrawal
An Outside withdrawal is money taken out of a broker to somewhere you do not track, such as a bank account that is not in your Wallet: to an account in your Wallet, it is a Withdraw from broker instead. It lowers that broker's cash and counts as money you took out, never as a cost.
Open the window on the Broker tab
Press Add transaction on the Portfolio, or the + in the top bar, and pick the Broker tab.
Pick Outside withdrawal
Pick Outside withdrawal, Cash out to outside your accounts. There is no asset to choose: the form opens straight away.
Pick the day and the broker
Date is the day the money left the broker. Broker is the one it left: New broker adds one, and closed brokers are not listed.
Type the amount
Amount is what you took out. Its currency starts as the broker's: pick another beside the amount if the money left in another currency.
Broker cash out is what left the broker's cash, in the broker's currency. In one currency it is the amount: Matches the order total. Edit if the broker settled a different amount. Across two, it is worked out at the day's rate, marked FX, with the rate under it, such as Implied rate · 1 USD ≈ 0.9200 EUR. Type the broker's own figure if it differs; Reset goes back to the worked-out one.
Save it
A fee or a tax goes under Fees & tax, and tags or a note under Tags & notes. A new withdrawal starts as Cleared. Press Save transaction, and Transaction saved successfully confirms it. Keep open for the next one keeps the day and the broker for another.
Outside withdrawal or Withdraw from broker?
Both take money out of a broker. What decides is where the money went.
| Outside withdrawal, on the Broker tab | Withdraw from broker, on the Wallet tab | |
|---|---|---|
| The money went to | Somewhere you do not track: a bank account that is not in your Wallet, or someone else | One of your accounts in the Wallet |
| What it changes | The broker's cash | The broker's cash and the account's balance, in one record |
| Your net worth | Goes down by it, under Added at brokers | Stays the same: the money only moved |
| The Money in and out card | Not counted | Counts as money back from a broker, which lowers Invested |
| Where you change it | Activity, on the Portfolio | The Wallet. Activity shows it marked from the Wallet |
Never record both for the same money: the broker's cash would count it twice. With the Wallet switched off, there is no Wallet tab, so every withdrawal is an Outside withdrawal.
Every field
| Field | What to put in |
|---|---|
| Date | The day the money left the broker. It starts at now. |
| Broker | The broker it left. New broker adds one. |
| Amount | What you took out, more than 0, with its currency. |
| Broker cash out | What left the broker's cash, in its currency: the amount plus any fee and tax, at the day's rate when the currencies differ. Type the broker's figure if it differs. |
| Fees & tax | A Fee and a Tax, each with a currency. They raise Broker cash out. |
| Tags & notes | Tags to group it with others, and Notes. |
| Status | Uncleared or Cleared. A new one starts as Cleared. |
Worked example
| At DEGIRO, in April | Broker cash | Counts as |
|---|---|---|
| Cash before | €1,500.00 | |
| 10 Apr, outside withdrawal to a bank account you do not track | -€1,000.00 | Taken out |
| 10 Apr, the bank transfer's €2 fee, saved as a Broker expense | -€2.00 | Costs |
Good to know
An Outside withdrawal never counts in your return: it is your own money, leaving. A fee the broker charges is a Broker expense.
In Activity, tick it and use Change type: Outside deposit or withdrawal is Your own money in or out. Not counted in Total gain., and Broker income or expense is Interest, rebates and fees. Counted in Total gain. The broker's cash stays the same.
That is a Transfer / FX. If two files brought it as an Outside withdrawal and an Outside deposit, tick both in Activity and use Combine into one move.
A broker's file brings its withdrawals as outside withdrawals. One your Wallet already records as a Withdraw from broker is left out, as Your wallet already records this withdrawal, so it counts once.
Broker amount and Amount are required fields. means Broker cash out is empty. Across currencies with no rate for the day, it says Different currency. Enter the actual cash that moved at the broker.: type the broker's figure.
A broker cannot hold less than nothing. If its cash goes below zero after a withdrawal, a deposit or a sale is missing before it: see Cash at your brokers.