Why the numbers differ from your broker's
Your broker and Turbobulls often measure different things, such as which return, in which currency, at which price, and whether dividends, fees and taxes are counted. Compare the same measure and the two should agree.
The usual reasons
| What differs | Your broker often shows | Turbobulls shows |
|---|---|---|
| The return | The price gain on what you hold | Total return: price gain, gains from sales, dividends, less fees and taxes. Also a time-weighted and a money-weighted return |
| The currency | The account's currency, or the share's | Your workspace currency, converted at each day's rate |
| The price | A live price | The latest price in the app, not a live one; at weekends only crypto moves. Past days use each day's close |
| Dividends | Left out of a position's return | Counted in it, before tax, with the tax under fees and taxes |
| Dividend dates | The day it was paid | Your broker's day for a dividend from your file. A dividend from market data sits on its ex-dividend date |
| Gains on a sale | Often against your average price | Against your oldest purchases first |
Three returns, three answers
A simple return is the gain divided by the money you put in. The time-weighted return leaves out when you added or took out money, so it grades the investments. The money-weighted return counts your timing as well, and Turbobulls gives it as a yearly rate once the period is a year long. Your broker may show any one of them, and they can be far apart in the same year.
Worked example
| Date | What happened | Value after |
|---|---|---|
| 1 Jan | You put in €10,000 | €10,000 |
| 1 Jul | Up 10%, then you add €10,000 | €21,000 |
| 31 Dec | Down 10% | €18,900 |
The investments lost 1%. You lost more, because most of your money was in for the fall. All three are right: they answer different questions.
One holding, line by line
You bought 10 ASML at €600 with a €5 fee. It paid €60 in dividends, €9 of it withheld as tax, and it is at €650 now. Your broker's app shows +€500, the price gain. Turbobulls shows a Total return of +€546: €500 price gain, plus €60 dividends, less €14 fees and taxes.
Click the holding to see its parts. On every plan, Unrealized, on the shares you hold is the figure closest to your broker's, here +€500. The split into Price gain and Currency effect comes with Investing Pro and Turbo Pro.
Line them up
- Same period. Pick the dates your broker's report covers, with the period at the top of the bar.
- Same cash. Open the broker in Cash at brokers and type its statement's closing balance in Closing balance on the statement. Some imports keep a broker in one currency and convert money in a second currency at each day's rate, so the cash can differ a little from the broker's own figure. The import says so under Notes on your file, as Trading 212's note does: it starts This file also moves money in USD (12 rows), besides EUR. and ends the broker's cash can differ a little from what Trading 212 shows. DEGIRO with AutoFX off, Snowball, and eToro brought into a broker not kept in dollars do the same. See What the notes on your file mean.
- Same currency. Your workspace currency is in Settings, under General. On Investing Pro and Turbo Pro, the part of a return due to exchange rates shows as Currency effect.
Good to know
To compare with an index or a fund, use the time-weighted return: it is not moved by when you paid in.
Cash at a broker is never part of a return. It counts in your net worth.
If the same measure still differs, something is missing or doubled. Go through the checks for a value that looks wrong.